Bizarre Prophetic Commands/2

From AlHaTorah.org
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Bizarre Prophetic Commands

Exegetical Approaches

This topic has not yet undergone editorial review

Prophetic Vision

The bizarre actions commanded to prophets and their fulfillment took place only in prophetic visions.  They were meant to act only as analogies, not to be active public displays.

Prophetic standards – These sources find it unfathomable that Hashem would command his prophets to act in ways which would cause others to view them as unstable or mad. If a prophet walks around naked, marries a prostitute, or lies on his side for months on end, how can he earn the respect of the people and have his rebukes to be heard?
Transgressions
No mention of vision
Intended audience
Efficacy of prophecy

Symbolic Action

Hashem's commands were actively fulfilled, despite the embarrassment or pain they might have caused the prophet.  This position subdivides, with some commentators assuming that all the commands were fulfilled to the letter and others re-interpreting Hashem's words to mitigate the difficulty their fulfillment might pose for the prophet.

Literal Fulfillment

Hashem's commands are understood literally, without an attempt to soften the directives or make life easier for the prophet.

Non-literal Fulfillment

Many of Hashem's commands are reinterpreted, easing their fulfillment and making them accord more with the standards of behavior expected of a prophet.