Achashverosh's Shock and Fury/1
Achashverosh's Surprise
Introduction
Why So Shocked?
Esther Chapter Seven contains one of the most dramatic scenes of the Megillah. Esther pleas for her life and that of her nation, finally revealing her identity and exposing Haman's plot to the king. Achashverosh responds with shock, asking "מִי הוּא זֶה וְאֵי זֶה הוּא", who is the one who conceived of such a plan? Upon hearing that Haman is the mastermind, he leaves the room in a fury.
How is one to understand the king's surprised reaction? How could he not know of Haman's involvement? After all, it was just a few days earlier that he gave his approval for the plan! Even if the king had been unaware until this moment that Esther was to be a victim, he still should have known that Haman was the plan's architect! Moreover, considering that he himself had played a role, why is Achashverosh so angry at Haman?
Esther's Plan
Esther's plea also raise several questions. At first glance, it seems as if she is simply begging for mercy on the part of the king, hoping he will spare her and her nation. If so though, one wonders why she does so at a party to which she has also invited Haman! Moreover, though the king might have a personal interest in keeping her alive, if he truly wanted to annihilate her nation, why does she think that her begging would lead him to reverse the edict rather than simply save her? Finally, why does she mention the potential alternative of being sold into slavery; how does this strengthen her argument?
Haman's request of the King
A full understanding of Achashverosh and Esther's conversation requires th reader to go back to Haman's original request to annihilate the Jewish nation:
a
