Difference between revisions of "Biblical Parallels Index – Shemot 4/0"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This topic has not yet undergone editorial review
m |
m |
||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
</category> | </category> | ||
<category>Hardened Hearts | <category>Hardened Hearts | ||
| − | <p> | + | <p>Paroh is the first of three people or groups of people of whom Hashem says He will harden their hearts. The other two are Sichon (Devarim 2:30) and the Canaanites (Yehoshua 11:20). Comparing the various narratives might help one understand both what is meant by the expression and how to deal with the theological problem of Hashem's apparent removal of free will in these stories.</p> |
<subcategory>Tools | <subcategory>Tools | ||
<ul> | <ul> | ||
| − | <li>See<a href="https://mg.alhatorah.org/Dual/Biblical_Parallels/Shemot/4.21#m5e3n6"> Makbilot Bamikra</a> for a list and links to | + | <li>See<a href="https://mg.alhatorah.org/Dual/Biblical_Parallels/Shemot/4.21#m5e3n6"> Makbilot Bamikra</a> for a list and links to all the verses which speak of Hashem hardening someone's heart.</li> |
</ul> | </ul> | ||
</subcategory> | </subcategory> | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
</category> | </category> | ||
<category>Moshe and Yosef | <category>Moshe and Yosef | ||
| − | <p>One may draw parallels between the stories of Yosef and Moshe.  Both experience rejection at the hands of their brethren in their place of birth<fn>Yosef suffers at the hands of his brothers in Israel and Moshe at the hands of his Jewish brethren in Egypt after he kills the Egyptian taskmaster.</fn> and both escape to a new place where they must decide whether to integrate into the foreign society | + | <p>One may draw parallels between the stories of Yosef and Moshe.  Both experience rejection at the hands of their brethren in their place of birth<fn>Yosef suffers at the hands of his brothers in Israel and Moshe at the hands of his Jewish brethren in Egypt after he kills the Egyptian taskmaster.</fn> and both escape to a new place where they must decide whether or not to integrate into the foreign society in which they now live. Ultimately, each saves their brothers, one by bringing them to Egypt and one by leading them out.<fn>One may note that these parallels demonstrate the different scope and character of Bereshit and Shemot; whereas the brothers of Yosef are his actual biological brothers and the narrative is confined to the family unit, the brothers of Moshe are the entire Jewish people and the narrative is national in scope.</fn>  </p> |
<subcategory>Sources | <subcategory>Sources | ||
<ul> | <ul> | ||
| − | <li>See <a href="DevarimRabbahVilna2-8" data-aht="source">Devarim Rabbah (Vilna) 2:8</a> which contrasts Yosef and Moshe, noting that only the former merits to be buried in Israel.  The Midrash suggests that this is because Yosef associates and identifies himself as an "עברי" whereas when Yitro's daughters refer to Moshe as Egyptian, he does not correct their misconception and identify as a Hebrew.</li> | + | <li>See <a href="DevarimRabbahVilna2-8" data-aht="source">Devarim Rabbah (Vilna) 2:8</a> which contrasts Yosef and Moshe, noting that only the former merits to be buried in Israel.  The Midrash suggests that this is because Yosef associates and identifies himself as an "עברי" whereas when Yitro's daughters refer to Moshe as Egyptian, he does not correct their misconception and identify himself as a Hebrew.</li> |
</ul> | </ul> | ||
</subcategory> | </subcategory> | ||
Version as of 09:46, 7 August 2023
Biblical Parallels Index – Shemot 4
Initiation Prophecies
It is fruitful to compare and contrast Moshe’s initial prophecy (נבואת הקדשה) in Shemot 3-4, with that of others, such as Gideon (Shofetim Chapter 6), Shemuel (Shemuel I Chapter 3), Yeshayahu (Yeshayahu Chapter 6), Yirmeyahu (Yirmeyahu Chapter 1), and Yechezkel (Ycehezkel Chapter 1), in order to note the similarities and differences that reflect the unique personality and mission of each prophet.
Articles
- Among the most salient aspects of Moshe’s initial prophecy is his great reluctance to accept his mission. Several of Nechama Leibowitz’s gilyonot on this chapter focus on understanding Moshe’s reluctance.1
- See Before I Formed You in the Belly I Knew You: Yirmiyahu’s Prophecy of Consecration, by R. David Sabato, for analysis of the essential components of prophecies of consecration, with a focus on Yirmeyahu.
- See Shemuel’s Consecration Prophecy by R. Amnon Bazak for comparison of Moshe’s and Shemuel’s consecration prophecies.
Hardened Hearts
Paroh is the first of three people or groups of people of whom Hashem says He will harden their hearts. The other two are Sichon (Devarim 2:30) and the Canaanites (Yehoshua 11:20). Comparing the various narratives might help one understand both what is meant by the expression and how to deal with the theological problem of Hashem's apparent removal of free will in these stories.
Tools
- See Makbilot Bamikra for a list and links to all the verses which speak of Hashem hardening someone's heart.
Articles
- See Hardened Hearts for analysis of different approaches to the hardening of human beings’ hearts in Tanakh.
- See And I Will Harden The Heart of Pharaoh, by R. Yaakov Medan, for a unified interpretation of the hardening of the hearts of Pharaoh, Sichon, and Canaan. He suggests that in all three cases the characters never fully lost their free will.
Moshe and Yosef
One may draw parallels between the stories of Yosef and Moshe. Both experience rejection at the hands of their brethren in their place of birth2 and both escape to a new place where they must decide whether or not to integrate into the foreign society in which they now live. Ultimately, each saves their brothers, one by bringing them to Egypt and one by leading them out.3
Sources
- See Devarim Rabbah (Vilna) 2:8 which contrasts Yosef and Moshe, noting that only the former merits to be buried in Israel. The Midrash suggests that this is because Yosef associates and identifies himself as an "עברי" whereas when Yitro's daughters refer to Moshe as Egyptian, he does not correct their misconception and identify himself as a Hebrew.
Articles
- In his article Moshe’s Delay and God’s Encouragement, R. Gad Eldad points out some of the parallels between Yosef and Moshe and explores how Torah hints to Moshe’s process of deciding to commit to Hashem’s mission after experiencing the rejection of his brethren and escaping to Midyan.
Yaakov and Esav, Moshe and Aharon
There are parallels between the narrative of the anticipated reunion of Yaakov and Esav in Bereshit 32-33 and the reunion of Moshe and Aharon in Shemot 4.4
Tools
- Concordance – The concordance demonstrates that the root "פגש" appears only four times in Torah, twice in each of these stories, perhaps a linguistic hint to compare the two.
Sources
- See Rashbam who draws parallels between the stories of Yaakov’s and Moshe’s near-death encounters with angels in Bereshit 32 and Shemot 4, noting that both relate to a refusal/delay to fulfill a mission.
Articles
- See Moses in Danger, by R. Alex Israel, for an exploration of these parallel stories, who, like Rashbam, suggests that both relate to a character's avoidance of a mission and the repercussions of such delay.5
