Difference between revisions of "Literary Devices – Bereshit 32/0"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This topic has not yet undergone editorial review
m |
m |
||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
<subcategory>אדון ועבד (master and servant) | <subcategory>אדון ועבד (master and servant) | ||
<p>Tanakh Lab demonstrates that the words “אדון” and "עבד" appear frequently in Bereshit 32-33 (the narrative of Yaakov’s reunion with Esav).<fn>The word "אדון" appears 8 times, and the word "עבד" nine times.</fn> This language underscores Yaakov’s mistrust of Esav and his need to be strategically deferential when relating to him. On the backdrop of the prophetic promise of Esav’s eventual subservience to Yaakov (25:23) and Yaakov's taking Yitzchak’s blessing "Be master over your brothers" (27:29), such subservience is very ironic. The fact that the text refers to Esav and Yaakov as brothers 7 times in this unit, and Yaakov nonetheless feels the need to pose as "servant", further highlights Yaakov's fear that Esav was perhaps not ready to view him as "brother".<fn>Esav, though, does in fact refer to Yaakov as "my brother" in Bereshit 33:9, and see Rashbam that throughout Esav had no evil intent.</fn></p> | <p>Tanakh Lab demonstrates that the words “אדון” and "עבד" appear frequently in Bereshit 32-33 (the narrative of Yaakov’s reunion with Esav).<fn>The word "אדון" appears 8 times, and the word "עבד" nine times.</fn> This language underscores Yaakov’s mistrust of Esav and his need to be strategically deferential when relating to him. On the backdrop of the prophetic promise of Esav’s eventual subservience to Yaakov (25:23) and Yaakov's taking Yitzchak’s blessing "Be master over your brothers" (27:29), such subservience is very ironic. The fact that the text refers to Esav and Yaakov as brothers 7 times in this unit, and Yaakov nonetheless feels the need to pose as "servant", further highlights Yaakov's fear that Esav was perhaps not ready to view him as "brother".<fn>Esav, though, does in fact refer to Yaakov as "my brother" in Bereshit 33:9, and see Rashbam that throughout Esav had no evil intent.</fn></p> | ||
| + | </subcategory> | ||
| + | <subcategory>פנים (face / before) | ||
| + | <ul> | ||
| + | <li><a href="https://mg.alhatorah.org/TanakhLab/Bereshit/32/1/33/20">Tanakh Lab</a> demonstrates that the word that appears with greatest frequency in both Chapter 32 alone and in the unit of Chapters 32-33 is "פנים".‎<fn>In Bereshit 32:21 it appears a full four times! Additionally, Chapter 32 concludes with Yaakov naming the place "Peniel" (or Penuel) because “I saw God face to face and my life was saved".</fn>  The usage of the term in the context of "going before", "appeasing the face" and "seeing the face" which all refer to submission to authority,<fn>See commentators on verse 21.</fn> might relate to the motif of Yaakov’s ironic subservience to Esav so prevalent in this unit, as discussed above.</li> | ||
| + | <li>More broadly, though, the keyword of “פנים” relates to the most prominent theme of Yaakov’s narrative, which is about deceit and revelation.  The key drama of Yaakov’s life is his presentation of himself as Esav, followed by Lavan’s deception of him by presenting Leah as Rachel.  In these climactic chapters of his narrative, Yaakov experiences a powerful revelation of Hashem followed by a face-to-face encounter with Esav.  This symbolizes a trajectory away from cunning and concealment, toward looking things in the face.  This is perhaps reflected by Rashi’s comment on the change of Yaakov’s name to Yisrael in this chapter:  “לא יאמרו עליך עוד שהברכות בעקיבה וברמייה, כי אם בשררה ובגילוי פנים"</li> | ||
| + | </ul> | ||
</subcategory> | </subcategory> | ||
</category> | </category> | ||
Version as of 06:40, 5 July 2023
Literary Devices – Bereshit 32
Structure
Parallels and Contrasts
Key Words
אדון ועבד (master and servant)
Tanakh Lab demonstrates that the words “אדון” and "עבד" appear frequently in Bereshit 32-33 (the narrative of Yaakov’s reunion with Esav).1 This language underscores Yaakov’s mistrust of Esav and his need to be strategically deferential when relating to him. On the backdrop of the prophetic promise of Esav’s eventual subservience to Yaakov (25:23) and Yaakov's taking Yitzchak’s blessing "Be master over your brothers" (27:29), such subservience is very ironic. The fact that the text refers to Esav and Yaakov as brothers 7 times in this unit, and Yaakov nonetheless feels the need to pose as "servant", further highlights Yaakov's fear that Esav was perhaps not ready to view him as "brother".2
פנים (face / before)
- Tanakh Lab demonstrates that the word that appears with greatest frequency in both Chapter 32 alone and in the unit of Chapters 32-33 is "פנים".3 The usage of the term in the context of "going before", "appeasing the face" and "seeing the face" which all refer to submission to authority,4 might relate to the motif of Yaakov’s ironic subservience to Esav so prevalent in this unit, as discussed above.
- More broadly, though, the keyword of “פנים” relates to the most prominent theme of Yaakov’s narrative, which is about deceit and revelation. The key drama of Yaakov’s life is his presentation of himself as Esav, followed by Lavan’s deception of him by presenting Leah as Rachel. In these climactic chapters of his narrative, Yaakov experiences a powerful revelation of Hashem followed by a face-to-face encounter with Esav. This symbolizes a trajectory away from cunning and concealment, toward looking things in the face. This is perhaps reflected by Rashi’s comment on the change of Yaakov’s name to Yisrael in this chapter: “לא יאמרו עליך עוד שהברכות בעקיבה וברמייה, כי אם בשררה ובגילוי פנים"
