Patterns in the Plagues/1/he

חלוקת המכות

הקדמה

R. Yehuda's Acronyms

A very famous set of acronyms for the Ten Plagues is cited in the Passover Haggadah¹ in the name of R. Yehuda:

רבי יהודה היה נותן בהם סימנים: דצ"ך עד"ש באח"ב. 

What is the need for and significance of R. Yehuda's teaching?² Is he simply providing a mnemonic to facilitate keeping track of all of the miracles,³ or is he attempting to convey a more profound understanding of how to categorize and comprehend the relationships between the various plagues?

Multiple Divisions

Regardless of R. Yehuda's personal intent, his acronyms have inspired many commentators, even some who do not ordinarily engage in structural analysis, to search for patterns among the plagues and to attempt to understand their ordering. While some suffice with showing how the Plagues form a cohesive linear progression, others split the larger series into pairs, triads, pentads, and hextads, each unified either in purpose or by certain common characteristics.

¹ See also Sifre DevarimDevarim 301About Sifre Devarim and Midrash TannaimDevarim 26About Midrash Tannaim.

² See the formulation in the Haggadah commentary of R. Yeshayah MiTrani: "תימה, מה סימן נתן ר' יהודה? וכי אין אדם יודע ליקח מכל תיבה אות ולעשות סימן?", and similarly in the Haggadah commentary attributed to Rashi: "זיל קרי בי רב הוא".

³ See R. N"H WesselyRuach Chen 12 (pp.210-224)Yein Levanon Avot 5:5Shirei Tiferet, Intro. to Vol. 3About R. Naftali Herz Wessely who suggests exactly that, and see R. Yehuda b. Yakar, Ritva, and R. Shimon b. Tzemach Duran in their commentaries on the Haggadah who note that R. Yehuda offers a mnemonic also in a different context in Bavli MenachotMenachot 96aAbout the Bavli.