Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Devarim/0/en

Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Devarim

Contradictory Accounts

In Sefer Devarim, Moshe recounts several episodes described in earlier books of the Torah. Often, these accounts differ on key points.  In some cases, they even appear to contradict each other. How are we to understand the variations?

• Compare the accounts of the story of the Spies as narrated in both Parashat Shelach and Parashat Devarim. What differences do you note? Which are the most troubling? How might you explain them?  Do the same for the description of the conquests of Sichon and Og in Parashat Chukkat and Parashat Devarim. 
• What are the overall objectives and messages of Moshe's historical speech in the opening chapters of Sefer Devarim and how might these affect the way that he retells earlier stories?
• Is it problematic to say that Moshe intentionally recasts history to promote an agenda?

For more, see The Story of the Spies in Bemidbar and Devarim and Battles with Sichon and Og in Bemidbar and Devarim.

The Spies' Route and Slander

Did the Spies really travel from the Wilderness of Zin all the way to Israel's northern border, evaluating the country's main cities, fortifications, and water sources along the way, and then returning to Moshe, all within a span of forty days?

• While Rashi asserts that special Divine providence hastened the Spies' pace and enabled them to explore the entire land, the Netziv claims that the spies scouted in pairs, dividing up the country between them.  Some modern scholars, in contrast, suggest that the spies scouted only the southern region of the land, as that was intended to be their entry point into the land, and the first stage of its conquest.
• Which verses support each position? Which are difficult?
• How do the different positions shed light on the nature of the Spies' sin as a whole?  How might our evaluation of the spies differ if Chevron was the sole city visited, rather than merely one stop of many?  What ramifications might there have been if only one or two of the spies encountered the giants, or if all of them did? For discussion, see The Spies – Where Did They Tour?

Moshe's Assistants

The very first event Moshe chooses to recount in his speech in Devarim 1 is his enlisting of leadership to aid in "bearing the burden" of the nation. It is not clear, however, to which episode Moshe is referring.  Is it the implementation of Yitro's advice in Shemot 18, the appointing of elders in Bemidbar 11, or some combination.

• What is the relationship between the appointments of Shemot and Bemidbar?  Do these accounts describe two distinct events or tell of one event from different perspectives?  If Moshe had already appointed assistants in Shemot, why would he need others in Bemidbar?  Finally, which aspects of Moshe's retelling in Devarim match each account?  See Appointing Moshe's Assistants for more.
• In Shemot, what does Yitro suggest are the necessary qualifications for the judges?  What qualifications does Moshe speak of in Devarim?  How do these relate to one another? How would your own list compare? Was Moshe able to find people with all of these qualities? See אנשי חיל and Advice and Implementation.
• What are "rulers of thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens"?  Does this refer to the numbers of people over whom each group of judges was supposed to rule?  If so, the mathematical calculations would produce a figure of 78,600 judges for a population of only 600,000 men, making for a very large bureaucracy. Are there other ways these terms could be understood?  See Yitro's System – A Bloated Bureaucracy?

Hardened Hearts

Devarim 2 notes that Sichon refused to allow the Israelites to pass through his land because "Hashem hardened his spirit and made his heart obstinate."  The verse suggests that Hashem manipulated Sichon so as to cause his defeat at the hands of Israel.

• What does this episode suggest about man's free will? Are there circumstances under which Hashem chooses to override this principle? If Hashem does indeed take away someone's free choice, how can He hold the person responsible for their actions?
• There are many events that Tanakh attributes to Hashem, saying, "it was the hand of God" or the like.  Are all of these cases miraculous wonders, or might they have happened through natural order?  If the latter, why are these instances described as Hashem's doing?
• The best known example of Hashem's hardening of hearts is the case of Paroh and the Egyptians. Can you think of examples of modern "Paroh's" who similarly refuse to capitulate in the face of definite defeat, knowing that it will lead to the destruction or suffering of their nations?  What leads these modern figures to "harden their hearts"?  Can the hardened hearts of Biblical characters be explained in similar fashion?

For further discussion of the above, see Hardened Hearts