Difference between revisions of "The Suffering Servant in Yeshayahu 53/2/en"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This topic has not yet undergone editorial review
m |
m |
||
Line 60: | Line 60: | ||
</ul></point> | </ul></point> | ||
<point><b>"חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" – Vicarious punishment?</b><ul> | <point><b>"חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" – Vicarious punishment?</b><ul> | ||
− | <li>According to R. Eliezer of Beaugency<fn>See also the third possibility brought by R. Saadia.</fn> the chapter does not imply that Yirmeyahu vicariously suffered for others' sins.  Rather, he made himself sick thinking about the tragedies that were to come | + | <li>According to R. Eliezer of Beaugency<fn>See also the third possibility brought by R. Saadia.</fn> the chapter does not imply that Yirmeyahu vicariously suffered for others' sins.  Rather, he made himself sick thinking about the tragedies that were to come to the nation due to their evil deeds.<fn>See his lament, "עַל שֶׁבֶר בַּת עַמִּי הׇשְׁבָּרְתִּי" (<a href="Yirmeyahu8-21-23" data-aht="source">Yirmeyahu 8:21</a>).</fn></li> |
− | <li>R. Saadia also raises the possibility that Hashem did truly afflict Yirmeyahu | + | <li>R. Saadia also raises the possibility that Hashem did truly afflict Yirmeyahu so that he would earn merit to pray for Israel and attain atonement for their sins.  This is not unjust, as Yirmeyahu would be compensated for any suffering in the Next World.  [See <a href="Philosophy:Theodicy – צדיק ורע לו" data-aht="page">Theodicy – צדיק ורע לו</a>, where R. Saadia uses similar reasoning to explain why sometimes the righteous suffer while the evil prosper.]</li> |
</ul></point> | </ul></point> | ||
<point><b>"מוּסַר שְׁלוֹמֵנוּ עָלָיו וּבַחֲבֻרָתוֹ נִרְפָּא לָנוּ"</b> – These sources might explain this verse in one of two ways:<br/> | <point><b>"מוּסַר שְׁלוֹמֵנוּ עָלָיו וּבַחֲבֻרָתוֹ נִרְפָּא לָנוּ"</b> – These sources might explain this verse in one of two ways:<br/> | ||
<ul> | <ul> | ||
<li>R"E of Beaugency suggests that the people were saying that while Yirmeyahu was distressed at the sinful state of the nation, they carried on as if nothing was amiss, saying "שלום יהיה לנו".  Due to the encouraging messages of the false prophets, they thought they were "cured" and healthy, with nothing to fear.<fn>See Yirmeyahu's speech about false prophets in Yirmeyahu 8:11, "וַיְרַפּוּ אֶת שֶׁבֶר בַּת עַמִּי עַל נְקַלָּה לֵאמֹר שָׁלוֹם שָׁלוֹם וְאֵין שָׁלוֹם".</fn> </li> | <li>R"E of Beaugency suggests that the people were saying that while Yirmeyahu was distressed at the sinful state of the nation, they carried on as if nothing was amiss, saying "שלום יהיה לנו".  Due to the encouraging messages of the false prophets, they thought they were "cured" and healthy, with nothing to fear.<fn>See Yirmeyahu's speech about false prophets in Yirmeyahu 8:11, "וַיְרַפּוּ אֶת שֶׁבֶר בַּת עַמִּי עַל נְקַלָּה לֵאמֹר שָׁלוֹם שָׁלוֹם וְאֵין שָׁלוֹם".</fn> </li> | ||
− | <li>Alternatively, Yirmeyahu's | + | <li>Alternatively, Yirmeyahu's prayer</li> |
</ul></point> | </ul></point> | ||
<point><b>"כִּי נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים"</b></point> | <point><b>"כִּי נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים"</b></point> |
Version as of 07:26, 21 September 2018
The Suffering Servant in Yeshayahu 53
Exegetical Approaches
The Nation of Israel
Sources:Bemidbar Rabbah, Rashi,1 R. Yosef Kara, Kuzari, Ibn Ezra, Radak, R. Yosef ibn Kaspi, R. Eliezer Ashkenazi,2 Abarbanel #1,3 Shadal, Hoil Moshe, Biur,
Identity of the servant – According to this approach, the servant is the nation of Israel, or at least the righteous among them.4 This reading matches the larger context, as both the preceding and following prophecies speak of Israel.5 In addition, throughout Yeshayahu, the term "עַבְדִּי" often refers to the nation. See, for instance, "וְאַתָּה יִשְׂרָאֵל עַבְדִּי" (41:8), "אַל תִּירָא עַבְדִּי יַעֲקֹב" (44:2), and "עַבְדִּי אָתָּה יִשְׂרָאֵל" (49:3).6
The onlookers – These are members of foreign nations who looked down upon Israel in exile and witnessed her suffering.
"נִבְזֶה וַחֲדַל אִישִׁים" – When was the servant degraded? The various descriptions of humiliation and anguish refer to the nation's experiences in exile, where they suffered extensively at the hands of their oppressors, both physically7 and emotionally.8 While most of these sources assume that the prophet is speaking of the present exile, Ibn Kaspi9 maintains that he speaks of the Assyrian and Babylonian exiles.10
"הִנֵּה יַשְׂכִּיל עַבְדִּי" – When will the servant be exalted? These sources suggest one of two possibilities regarding this question (in line iowth their positions above):
- Messianic times – Most of the sources suggest that all the verses which speak of the servant's improved status11 refer to the End of Days.12 It is then that Israel will take vengeance on her enemies ("כֵּן יַזֶּה גּוֹיִם רַבִּים") and be blessed with long life ("יִרְאֶה זֶרַע יַאֲרִיךְ יָמִים").13 This will lead the foreign nations to recognize both the errors of their own beliefs and actions ("כֻּלָּנוּ כַּצֹּאן תָּעִינוּ") and the righteousness of Israel.14 An advantage of this reading is that these motifs are common in many of the surrounding prophecies which similarly speak of foreign recognition of both Israel and Hashem in the End of Days.15
- Second Temple Period – Ibn Kaspi, in contrast, asserts that the verses refer to the Second Temple Period when the nation returned to Israel.
"חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" – These sources differ regarding whether or not this verse implies vicarious punishment, and if not, what it means instead:
- No vicarious punishment – Most of these sources suggest that the words "חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" (and similar phrases throughout the chapter) do not connote that there was vicarious punishment.16
- Mistaken assumption – According to most of these commentators, the various phrases represent the perspective of the other nations, but are not a description of fact.17 Israel really suffered only for her own sins. However, when the nations finally recognize their earlier wickedness and Israel's righteousness, and try to reconcile this with their prosperity and Israel's afflictions, they erroneously conclude that Israel's suffering must have been vicarious punishment for their own sins.
- Admission of guilt – Ibn Ezra suggests, instead, that the words constitute an admission of guilt by the enemy nations. They confess to having inflicted suffering on Israel,18 referring to Israel's afflictions as "our sickness" only because they were the ones who caused them. Similarly, when they claim that Israel is "מְדֻכָּא מֵעֲוֺנֹתֵינוּ", they are saying that it was their sins, i.e. their oppression, which crushed Israel.19
- Vicarious punishment – In contrast to the other sources, the Kuzari appears to take the verses at face value and to assume that sometimes the righteous do suffer for the sins of others, even on the national level. All of humanity is one body, and Israel is its heart. As such, it both provides vitality to the rest of the body and finds itself under constant pressure and distress from the surrounding limbs (who meanwhile sit at rest). This position takes vicarious punishment to the extreme, claiming that it occurs not just within a family (פקד עון אבות) or even among members of the same nation, but that it can cross national borders.
"כִּי נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים" – Rashi, Radak, and Ibn Kaspi claim that this verse speaks not of death, but of exile. The nation was cut off from the land of Israel, an "אֶרֶץ חַיִּים".
"וַיִּתֵּן אֶת רְשָׁעִים קִבְרוֹ" – According to all these sources this verse speaks of the servant's actual death.20 This, however, creates no difficulty with his later receiving rewards in this world since the servant is identified with the nation rather than an individual. Though many individuals throughout history died by enemy hands, the nation as a whole will survive, bear fruit, and be esteemed by others.
Polemics
Other occurrences – Though this position could theoretically identify all the chapters as referring to Israel, not all commentators do,21 as certain verses in each of the chapters are difficult for such a position:
- Chapter 42:
- Chapter 49: At first glance the image of a servant who is being called by Hashem from birth ("מִבֶּטֶן קְרָאָנִי") would seem to refer to the appointment of a prophet. Hoil Moshe counters this by suggesting that it speaks of the early formation of the nation. Similarly, "וַיָּשֶׂם פִּי כְּחֶרֶב חַדָּה" seem to be a hint to the prophet's mouth which is uttering words of rebuke, though R. Eliezer of Beaugency rereads it that Israel will be strong against its enemies. In addition, Shadal points out that the presence of the phrase "וַיֹּאמֶר לִי עַבְדִּי אָתָּה יִשְׂרָאֵל" suggests that the prophecy as a whole refers to the Children of Israel.
Leader of Israel
Yirmeyahu
Sources:Opinion cited in R. Yehuda ibn Balaam, R. Saadia cited in Ibn Ezra, R. Eliezer of Beaugency,
Identity of the servant – Both R. Saadia and R"E of Beaugency suggest that the description of the servant might apply to almost any prophet.22 However, R. Saadia concludes that it most likely refers to Yirmeyahu, pointing to the many parallels to his life in particular:
- "וַיַּעַל כַּיּוֹנֵק לְפָנָיו" – Yirmeyahu began prophesying as a youngster, as he says of himself, "כִּי נַעַר אָנֹכִי" (Yirmeyahu 1:6).
- "וַחֲדַל אִישִׁים" – Throughout his life, Yirmeyahu was an outsider, distanced from other people, both by command23 and by circumstance,24 as he says, "מִפְּנֵי יָדְךָ בָּדָד יָשַׁבְתִּי" (Yirmeyahu 15:17).
- "נִבְזֶה וְלֹא חֲשַׁבְנֻהוּ"– When Yirmeyahu did interact with others, he was met with scorn, as evidenced by his complaint: "דַּע שְׂאֵתִי עָלֶיךָ חֶרְפָּה" (Yirmeyahu 15:15).
- "אִישׁ מַכְאֹבוֹת" – Yirmeyahu cries to Hashem, "לָמָּה הָיָה כְאֵבִי נֶצַח" (Yirmeyahu 15:18)
- "מֵעֹצֶר וּמִמִּשְׁפָּט לֻקָּח" – Yirmeyahu is imprisoned for his prophecies, as described in Yirmeyahu 32-33, 37-39: "בִּהְיֹתוֹ עָצוּר בַּחֲצַר הַמַּטָּרָה".
- "נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים" – Yirmeyahu's opponents attempted to kill him on several occasions, saying "וְנִכְרְתֶנּוּ מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים" (Yirmeyahu 11:19)
- "כַּשֶּׂה לַטֶּבַח יוּבָל" – Yirmeyahu says of himself, "וַאֲנִי כְּכֶבֶשׂ אַלּוּף יוּבַל לִטְבוֹחַ" (Yirmeyahu 11:19).
"נִבְזֶה וַחֲדַל אִישִׁים" – When was the servant degraded? As seen above, throughout his tenure as prophet, Yirmeyahu was demeaned, afflicted, imprisoned, and even had his life threatened.
"הִנֵּה יַשְׂכִּיל עַבְדִּי" – When will the servant be exalted? Abarbanel questions how the servant might be identified with Yirmeyahu considering that he was never exalted in his lifetime and there is no evidence that he received the rewards described in the chapter. This leads R. Saadia to reinterpret many of the seemingly problematic verses:
- "הִנֵּה יַשְׂכִּיל עַבְדִּי" – R. Saadia understands " יַשְׂכִּיל" to mean attainment of wisdom rather than success, and assumes that the phrase refers to a past rather than future event. Hashem gave wisdom to Yirmeyahu when he first started to prophesy since he was such a youth.
- "יָרוּם וְנִשָּׂא וְגָבַהּ מְאֹד" – These words do not imply that Yirmeyahu was to be respected at the end of his life, but that Hashem gave him the strength to withstand and overcome his enemies,25 as He promises, "נְתַתִּיךָ הַיּוֹם לְעִיר מִבְצָר וּלְעַמּוּד בַּרְזֶל וּלְחֹמוֹת נְחֹשֶׁת עַל כׇּל הָאָרֶץ... וְנִלְחֲמוּ אֵלֶיךָ וְלֹא יוּכְלוּ לָךְ".
- "מִי הֶאֱמִין לִשְׁמֻעָתֵנוּ וּזְרוֹעַ י"י עַל מִי נִגְלָתָה" – This, too, refers to an event which took place early in Yirmeyahu's career, when people were surprised that Hashem had given prophecy to such a young child
- "כֵּן יַזֶּה גּוֹיִם רַבִּים" – R. Saadia translates "יַזֶּה" as "to disperse" and suggests that the phrase speaks of Yirmeyahu's prophecies of exile to the foreign nations.
- "עָלָיו יִקְפְּצוּ מְלָכִים פִּיהֶם" – This refers to Nebuchadnezzar's sparing of Yirmeyahu.
- "יִרְאֶה זֶרַע יַאֲרִיךְ יָמִים וְחֵפֶץ י"י בְּיָדוֹ יִצְלָח" – According to R. Saadia this is a blessing that is to come on Israel (and not Yirmeyahu). Due to Yirmeyahu's chastisements, the nation will merit long life in Hashem's land.
- "לָכֵן אֲחַלֶּק לוֹ בָרַבִּים וְאֶת עֲצוּמִים יְחַלֵּק שָׁלָל" – This refers to the reward Yirmeyahu is to receive in the World to Come, when he will be resurrected together with the other righteous leaders and share with them Hashem's "booty"; i.e. everlasting life.26
"חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" – Vicarious punishment?
- According to R. Eliezer of Beaugency27 the chapter does not imply that Yirmeyahu vicariously suffered for others' sins. Rather, he made himself sick thinking about the tragedies that were to come to the nation due to their evil deeds.28
- R. Saadia also raises the possibility that Hashem did truly afflict Yirmeyahu so that he would earn merit to pray for Israel and attain atonement for their sins. This is not unjust, as Yirmeyahu would be compensated for any suffering in the Next World. [See Theodicy – צדיק ורע לו, where R. Saadia uses similar reasoning to explain why sometimes the righteous suffer while the evil prosper.]
"מוּסַר שְׁלוֹמֵנוּ עָלָיו וּבַחֲבֻרָתוֹ נִרְפָּא לָנוּ" – These sources might explain this verse in one of two ways:
- R"E of Beaugency suggests that the people were saying that while Yirmeyahu was distressed at the sinful state of the nation, they carried on as if nothing was amiss, saying "שלום יהיה לנו". Due to the encouraging messages of the false prophets, they thought they were "cured" and healthy, with nothing to fear.29
- Alternatively, Yirmeyahu's prayer
"כִּי נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים"
"וַיִּתֵּן אֶת רְשָׁעִים קִבְרוֹ"
"עַבְדִּי" – R. Saadia suggests that the servant can include all of the prophets who rebuked the nation and were disrespected while filling their role, or refer to a specific prophet. R. Eliezer of Beaugency explains the chapter according to the first option, however, R. Saadia himself explains it about Yirmeyahu since he is the only prophet that matches all the descriptions of the servant in Yeshayahu.30
Context of the Prophecy – Ibn Ezra notes that there is no relationship between the surrounding chapters of comfort and Yirmeyahu's suffering.
King
Sources:Bavli Sotah, Ibn Chiquitilla cited in R. Yehuda ibn Balaam, opinion cited by R. Eliezer Ashkenazi, Abarbanel #2
Who is the servant?
- Ibn Chiquitilla explains the servant to be Chizkiyahu. However, Ibn Balaam notes that we don't know anything about Chizkiyahu suffering, and that the description of "לֹא תֹאַר לוֹ וְלֹא הָדָר" does not match him.31
- Abarbanel reads the chapter as referring to Yoshiyahu, one of the few historical figures of the period who suffered without sinning himself. Yoshiyahu did not suffer throughout his life rather only in his early death when he was killed in battle with Paroh Necho.
"הִנֵּה יַשְׂכִּיל עַבְדִּי" – When? In contrast to other commentators who assert that "יַשְׂכִּיל" is referring to future prosperity that will come upon the servant, Abarbanel understands it to refer to the success and perfection of Yoshiyahu in the beginning of his reign before he suffered. He understands "יַשְׂכִּיל" in the meaning of understanding, that Yoshiyahu learned to walk in Hashem's path and worshiped Him with all his heart.
"מִשְׁחַת מֵאִישׁ מַרְאֵהוּ" – The descriptions of the person being despicable are referring to Paroh Necho who fought against Yoshiyahu. The prophet is speaking in the name of the nation who are surprised how such a righteous man was killed by such a shamed enemy. This reading is a little surprising that the verses suddenly switch their subject from Yoshiyahu to Paroh Necho.
"חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" – Vicarious punishment?
"נִבְזֶה וַחֲדַל אִישִׁים" – When?
"כִּי נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים"
"וַיִּתֵּן אֶת רְשָׁעִים קִבְרוֹ"
Context of prophecy
Mashiach
Sources:Targum Yonatan,32 Bavli Sanhedrin, Tanchuma, Pesikta, Yefet b. Eli the Karaite, Ramban,33 Yalkut Shimoni,
"חֳלָיֵנוּ הוּא נָשָׂא" – Vicarious punishment?
"נִבְזֶה וַחֲדַל אִישִׁים" – When? Ramban explains that the Mashiach is upset about the sins of Israel which delayed his coming. Ramban also describes that when the Mashiach first appears, he will be poor and riding on a horse, and all the people will mock and curse him.
"הִנֵּה יַשְׂכִּיל עַבְדִּי" – When?
"כִּי נִגְזַר מֵאֶרֶץ חַיִּים"
"וַיִּתֵּן אֶת רְשָׁעִים קִבְרוֹ"
"עַבְדִּי" – According to this approach the servant is the Mashiach. The main motivation is that this prophecy comes in the midst of prophecies of comfort, which many say are talking about the days of the Mashiach.