Why Conceal Esther's Nationality/2

Concealing Esther's Religious Identity

Exegetical Approaches

This topic has not yet undergone editorial review

Personal Gain

The hiding of Esther's identity was meant to facilitate her being chosen as queen.

Sources:R. Yosef KaraEsther Version A 2:10Esther Version B 2:10About R. Yosef Kara, RashbamEsther 2:10Esther 2:19-20About R. Shemuel b. Meir, first opinion cited in Ibn EzraEsther Version A 2:9Esther Version B 2:10About R. Avraham ibn Ezra, Northern French CommentaryEsther 2:10About Northern French Commentary, opinion cited by R. Avigdor Kohen TzedekEsther 2:10About R. Avigdor Kohen Tzedek, R. Y"S ReggioEsther pp. 7-8About R. Yitzchak Shemuel Reggio

אֶת עַמָּהּ וְאֶת מוֹלַדְתָּהּ – What did Esther not tell? According to most of these exegetes, the words "עַמָּהּ וְמוֹלַדְתָּהּ" refer to Esther's Jewish nationality.  Esther did not want others to know that she was Jewish since the Jewish nation was degraded in the eyes of the Persians. The opinion brought in Ibn Ezra and Reggio emphasize instead that she wanted to conceal the fact that she came from exile ("מוֹלַדְתָּהּ") since this, rather than her Jewish roots, was the potential source of humiliation.¹

Until when did Esther not tell?

• R. Yosef Kara, Rashbam, and Reggio all claim that Esther hid her identity both before and after her coronation, presumably, lest she lose the crown upon revelation.
• Alternatively this position could posit that the secret was only necessary during the competition, to ensure that she was not automatically passed over due to her religion.  If so, the repeated mention of the fact of concealment after her coronation would have to be read as a summary statement for the chapter² or as related specifically to the second gathering of virgins, when competition was renewed.³

"וַתִּלָּקַח אֶסְתֵּר אֶל בֵּית הַמֶּלֶךְ" – The passive form of these words is difficult for this position as it makes it sound as if Esther was taken against her will, while these commentators assert that she was actively trying to be chosen.

"לֹא בִקְשָׁה דָּבָר" – These words, too, suggest a passivity on the part of Esther which does not fit the portrait of one who wishes to be chosen as queen.  Y. Hazony,⁴ though, suggests that in reality this was part of Esther's strategy.  The verse points out that Esther did not request anything on her own, but only, "אֲשֶׁר יֹאמַר הֵגַי סְרִיס הַמֶּלֶךְ שֹׁמֵר הַנָּשִׁים".  Esther realized that Hegai, a professional in charge of the king's harem,  knew best what it was that the king would want and thus followed his advice in all.

Esther and Mordechai's religious identity – Most of the commentators do not address the question but R. Y"S Reggio points out that Mordechai and Esther do not seem overly concerned with observing the commandments.  Thus, Mordechai never warns Esther to uphold belief in one God and reject Persian polytheism, nor to try and keep the laws of kashrut.  Instead, he does all in his power to get her to become queen, despite the fact that it will make observance more difficult.

Revealing the secret – R. Avigdor Kohen Tzedek questions this approach from Achashverosh's attitude upon Esther's revelation of her identity.  If her Judaism was abhorrent in his eyes, then it is not clear why Esther thought that revealing the fact should save her or her nation.  It should have been a cause for her rejection!  These exegetes might respond that by that point Esther had won over Achashverosh totally and he no longer cared about her origins.⁵

Religious Observance

Avoid Becoming Queen

Esther hid her identity in order to lower her chances of becoming Queen.

Sources:RashiEsther 2:10About R. Shelomo Yitzchaki, RidEsther 2:10Esther 2:19-21About R. Yeshayah of Trani

אֶת עַמָּהּ וְאֶת מוֹלַדְתָּהּ – What did Esther not tell? Rashi and Rid maintain that Esther was of royal lineage, being a descendant of King Shaul.  It was this lineage that Esther attempted to conceal as it would make her a more appealing candidate. Though this reading is sustained by the word "מוֹלַדְתָּהּ", it would be difficult to say that the word "עַמָּהּ" is limited to family status.

Was Esther from Shaul's family? Rashi asserts that "אִישׁ יְמִינִי" means that Mordechai was from the tribe of Binyamin and apparently assumes that the "קִישׁ" who is mentioned in Mordechai's genealogy is the same as the father of Shaul.  Ibn Ezra questions that if the verses wanted to highlight that he was a descendant of Shaul, though, it is strange that they would skip generations to mention Kish by name but not Shaul.

Esther and Mordechai's religious identity – These exegetes maintain that Mordechai and Esther were observant Jews,⁶ who were revolted by the concept that Esther should marry a Persian king, and be forced into a position where her faith and observance would be compromised.

Until when did Esther not tell? The verses suggest that Esther continued to conceal her identity even after she was chosen. This is somewhat difficult for this position, considering that such secrecy no longer served any purpose. Rashi suggests that once Esther was taken, Mordechai understood that she was meant to be a tool for the salvation of Israel and .  This could be why he would command her not to tell her identity even after she was chosen.

"וַתִּלָּקַח אֶסְתֵּר אֶל בֵּית הַמֶּלֶךְ" and "לֹא בִקְשָׁה דָּבָר" – These commentators point to these verses as evidence that Esther was taken by force and was trying to not be chosen.

Enable Torah Observance

The hiding of Esther's identity was to allow her to keep Mitzvot.

Sources:Ibn EzraEsther Version A 2:9Esther Version B 2:10About R. Avraham ibn Ezra's own opinion, Akeidat Yitzchak #1Esther 2:10About R. Yitzchak Arama

Which Mitzvot?

• Ibn Ezra holds that Mordechai was worried that Achashverosh would force Esther to go against the commandments if he knew she was Jewish but if he did not know she could keep Mitzvot in secret.
• The Akeidat Yitzchak says the concealment was in order that if Achasverosh forces Esther to go against one of the commandments it would not be בפרהסיא and the דין would not be יהרג ואל יעבור.

Esther and Mordechai's religious identity – Ibn Ezra holds that Esther

אֶת עַמָּהּ וְאֶת מוֹלַדְתָּהּ – What did Esther not tell? Both Ibn Ezra and Akeidat Yitzchak say that Esther hid the fact she was Jewish.

Until when did Esther not tell?

Was Esther taken by force?

National Interests

Agent of Salvation

Sources:Lekach TovEsther 2:10About R. Toviah b. Eliezer, R. Elazar HaRokeach #2Esther 2:10About R. Elazar HaRokeach, second opinion cited in Ibn EzraEsther Version A 2:9About R. Avraham ibn Ezra, RalbagEsther 2:10Esther 2 Toelet 15About R. Levi b. Gershom

Decreased Danger

Sources:Second Targum of Megillat Esther2:10About Second Targum of Megillat Esther, Midrash Panim Acherot #2Version B 2:10Version B 2:20About Midrash Panim Acherot, Yalkut Shimoni #2Esther 1053About Yalkut Shimoni

¹ In fact, Reggio asserts that Achashverosh had nothing against the Jewish nation, and even suggests that he never knowingly agreed to their annihilation.  Haman purposefully hid their identity when sharing his plan of decimation since he knew that the king would not have agreed. For elaboration, see Achashverosh's Surprise.

² See Rashbam who understands the phrase "וּבְהִקָּבֵץ בְּתוּלוֹת שֵׁנִית" to refer not to a second gathering of women, but to the original gathering mentioned previously so as to choose a "second", meaning an alternative to Vashti. [See Ibn Ezra who also thinks the verse refers to the gathering described earlier but understands "second" to be in contrast to the first gathering in which Vashti was chosen.]  According to this read, verses 19-20 would be a summary statement, rather than a description of new events. It is not clear, though, why this fact needed to be repeated. It should be noted, though, that Rashbam nonetheless asserts that Esther his her identity throughout.

³ This approach would presumably suggest that Haman did not tell Achashverosh which nation he was intending to destroy.   Thus, even if Achashverosh was aware of Esther's nationality by the time that Haman made his edict, he did not know that it applied to her. For elaboration of this general approach, see Achashverosh's Surprise.

⁴ See, The Dawn, (Jerusalem, 1995): 36-38.

⁵ This would be especially true for Reggio who maintains that she was only concealing that she came from exile and that Achashverosh was not negatively disposed towards the Jews.

⁶ Though the verses never mention any explicit religious observance, this need not connote that they did not keep Hashem's commandments.  According to Rashi, though Esther might have been forced not to keep some commandments when she was taken to the palace, she presumably kept all Mitzvot when at Mordechai's house.