Create the page "Collective Punishment" on this wiki! See also the search results found.

Page title matches

• Philosophy:Collective Punishment
  77 bytes (4 words) - 22:47, 10 July 2019
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/2
  <h1>Collective Punishment</h1> <point><b>Reward and punishment</b> – According to this position recompense comes to a person both in thi
  29 KB (4,359 words) - 02:54, 17 August 2017
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/5
  <h1>Collective Punishment</h1> ...se they worshipped these as gods. When the Holy One, blessed be He, exacts punishment from a nation, He punishes their gods at the same time (cf. Mekhilta on 12:
  249 KB (8,802 words) - 12:48, 28 January 2023
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/1/en
  <h1>Collective Punishment</h1> ...uring Korach's Rebellion</a>.</fn>&#160; Does Hashem agree that collective punishment is wrong or is it actually an integral part of His mode of justice?</p>
  7 KB (1,169 words) - 01:10, 12 May 2020
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/1/he
  ...>עכן עצמו נהרג רק לאחר מכן. לדיון מעמיק בסיפור זה, ראו <a href="Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin" data-aht="page">ענישה קולקטיבית על חטא
  9 KB (300 words) - 02:11, 20 September 2019
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/1/en
  <h1>Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</h1> <h2>The Punishment of Innocents</h2>
  6 KB (760 words) - 07:50, 23 September 2019
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/1/he
  ...וגישות בנושא הענישה הקולקטיבית בכללותה, ראו <a href="Philosophy:Collective Punishment" data-aht="page">ענישה קולקטיבית</a>.</fn>&#160;שאלה זו
  5 KB (89 words) - 10:26, 28 September 2019
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/2
  <h1>Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</h1> ...ocents are never punished, claim that the episode is not one of collective punishment at all and attempt to attribute sinful actions to the thirty six men who we
  23 KB (3,295 words) - 12:29, 28 January 2023
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/5
  <h1>Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</h1> ...of secret thoughts for these belong to the Lord our God and He will exact punishment from that individual; but those things which are revealed belong to us and
  86 KB (4,458 words) - 12:25, 28 January 2023
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin
  122 bytes (6 words) - 10:48, 18 July 2019

Page text matches

• Parashat Vayera/Questions
  ...m‎" data-aht="page">collective salvation </a>any more just than collective punishment? What was Avraham praying for in Sedom?</li>
  1 KB (176 words) - 20:49, 24 September 2017
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Vayera/0/en
  ...at a son raised by Avraham could have committed crimes so dire that such a punishment was warranted?</li> <category>Collective Punishment &amp; Collective Salvation
  6 KB (926 words) - 07:07, 26 January 2024
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/1/en
  <h1>Collective Punishment</h1> ...uring Korach's Rebellion</a>.</fn>&#160; Does Hashem agree that collective punishment is wrong or is it actually an integral part of His mode of justice?</p>
  7 KB (1,169 words) - 01:10, 12 May 2020
• Manifold Punishment/1/en
  <h1>Manifold Punishment</h1> <h2>Does the Punishment Fit the Crime?</h2>
  6 KB (795 words) - 00:45, 21 May 2020
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Korach/0/en
  ...n the entire nation for the crimes of a minority?&#160; When is collective punishment legitimate?</li> ...Fate in Art" data-aht="page">artistic depictions </a>of Datan and Aviram's punishment as an entree into a discussion of the following questions:&#160;</p>
  5 KB (751 words) - 08:49, 27 August 2019
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/1/en
  <h1>Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</h1> <h2>The Punishment of Innocents</h2>
  6 KB (760 words) - 07:50, 23 September 2019
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Ki Tetze/0/en
  ..." dovetail with all the cases in Tanakh where there seems to be collective punishment?</li> ...shment justified? Can the same reasoning apply to vicarious punishment? Is punishment within the perpetrator's family different?</li>
  6 KB (922 words) - 22:26, 4 September 2019
• Philosophy:Theodicy – צדיק ורע לו/1/en
  ...h as war, exile, and the like). In addition, Hashem's promise not to delay punishment would seem to imply that retribution is to occur before death. Nonetheless, ...see <a href="Philosophy:Collective Punishment" data-aht="page">Collective Punishment</a> and <a href="Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins" data-aht="page">A
  7 KB (1,094 words) - 01:08, 12 May 2020
• Dialogue with the Divine During Korach's Rebellion/1/en
  <li><b>Hashem</b> – Was Hashem threatening to impose collective punishment on the entire nation for the crimes of a minority, or was He always plannin ...see <a href="Philosophy:Collective Punishment" data-aht="page">Collective Punishment</a>.</fn></li>
  6 KB (878 words) - 12:45, 15 June 2020
• Purposes of the Egyptian Bondage/3/en
  <topic>Collective punishment
  2 KB (215 words) - 11:52, 28 January 2023
• Purpose of the Beheaded Heifer Ritual/2
  ...their zeal to find who is responsible so as to prevent possible collective punishment, the people might be quick to punish an innocent.</fn></p>
  7 KB (956 words) - 05:49, 10 January 2024
• Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins/1/en
  ...o the parent, his offspring, or both.</fn> or that the parents receive any punishment,<fn>Cf. "וְשַׂמְתִּי אֲנִי אֶת פָּנַי בָּאִי ...t form of penalty do the descendants receive, and is this really more of a punishment for their parents?</li>
  19 KB (2,741 words) - 00:52, 5 September 2019
• Avraham's Prayer for Sedom/1/en
  ...t would have constituted a readily comprehensible plea to avoid collective punishment.&#160; Sandwiched in between them, though, is verse 24 which, at first glan <h2>Collective Punishment vs. Collective Salvation</h2>
  12 KB (1,527 words) - 08:01, 30 July 2019
• Biblical Parallels Index – Shemot 5/0
  ...ssible that an individual will undeservedly be included in the rewards (or punishment) aimed at another, and fall prey to the vicissitudes of chance.&#160; This,
  2 KB (325 words) - 00:34, 29 December 2023
• David's Counting of the Nation/1/en
  ...rophe, it is not clear what sin was transgressed that led to such a severe punishment.&#160; How was David's census different from the many others in Tanakh whic ...he possible conclusion that the omission must have been the reason for the punishment.&#160; However, all other censuses in Tanakh also do not speak of half shek
  6 KB (808 words) - 23:17, 5 October 2019
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Shelach/0/en
  <li>How does such punishment manifest Divine justice?&#160; Moreover, why would Moshe mention such an at ...pply to vicarious punishment?&#160; Does the fact that the verse speaks of punishment within the family make a difference?</li>
  5 KB (790 words) - 13:17, 4 September 2019
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/2
  <h1>Collective Punishment</h1> <point><b>Reward and punishment</b> – According to this position recompense comes to a person both in thi
  29 KB (4,359 words) - 02:54, 17 August 2017
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/2
  <h1>Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</h1> ...ocents are never punished, claim that the episode is not one of collective punishment at all and attempt to attribute sinful actions to the thirty six men who we
  23 KB (3,295 words) - 12:29, 28 January 2023
• Manifold Punishment/2
  <h1>Manifold Punishment</h1> ...rs claim that the verses only make it seem that Hashem is excessive in His punishment. In reality, though, the people have either sinned more, or are punished le
  31 KB (4,320 words) - 03:57, 11 May 2020
• Reward and Punishment/1
  <h1>Reward and Punishment</h1> ...in other instances, specific mitzvot are singled out as meriting reward or punishment.<fn>See, for instance, rewards of longevity for honoring parents (<a href="
  13 KB (1,953 words) - 07:17, 6 May 2021
• Avraham and Yonah/0
  ...to the attempted salvation, raising important questions regarding sin and punishment and the desired balance between mercy and justice. ...קוֹם לְמַעַן חֲמִשִּׁים הַצַּדִּיקִם אֲשֶׁר בְּקִרְבָּהּ" as a request for collective salvation.&#160; Avraham asked that if there are a significant number of ri
  8 KB (1,019 words) - 00:11, 3 September 2020
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Ki Tisa/0/en
  ...pply to vicarious punishment?&#160; Does the fact that the verse speaks of punishment within the family make a difference?</li>
  7 KB (1,086 words) - 07:15, 23 August 2019
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Ki Tavo/0/en
  ...t we assume is a reward might actually be detrimental, and what we view as punishment might be beneficial. Similarly, people who we label as righteous might not ...l order, people can become victims of chance, or benefit together with the collective even when undeserving.&#160; Is it fair to delay retribution to the next wo
  4 KB (606 words) - 22:54, 4 September 2019
• Dialogue with the Divine During Korach's Rebellion/2
  ...ation the opportunity to distance themselves from Korach and thereby avoid punishment.</p> ...contemplate collectively punishing the nation.</fn> For more on collective punishment, see <a href="Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins" data-aht="page">Are
  35 KB (5,016 words) - 13:15, 28 January 2023
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Vaetchanan/0/en
  ...ning apply to vicarious punishment? Does the fact that the verse speaks of punishment within the family make a difference?</li>
  8 KB (1,245 words) - 11:31, 8 September 2019
• Avraham's Prayer for Sedom/2/en
  ...nishment, while his secondary appeal (to God's attribute of mercy) was for collective salvation.&#160;&#160;</p> ...reshold of ten for avoiding collective punishment and implementing instead collective salvation.&#160; R. Hirsch also views Avraham's arguments as a single one,
  47 KB (7,246 words) - 10:46, 28 January 2023
• Avraham's Prayer for Sedom/2/he
  ...ces agree that, in these words, Avraham is challenging Hashem's collective punishment<fn>R. Yosef Bekhor Shor asserts that Avraham understood from Hashem's words <li><b>Collective salvation</b> – Also according to R. D"Z Hoffmann, Avraham is really maki
  46 KB (6,689 words) - 11:14, 28 January 2023
• Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins/1/he
  ...ד) מתייחסת להורה, לצאצאיו, או לשניהם.</fn> or that the parents receive any punishment,<fn>השוו "וְשַׂמְתִּי אֲנִי אֶת פָּנַי בָּ� ...ונש קולקטיבי של המשפחה</b> – Do these verses advocate a form of collective punishment in which innocent children suffer for sins which they didn't commit?<fn>א�
  20 KB (1,449 words) - 01:24, 5 September 2019
• Why Was the Ark Taken/2
  ...captive and destruction of Shiloh.&#160; Rashi and others assume that the punishment must relate to the crime and conclude that if the ark was taken captive, th ...k being captured by the Philistines can be viewed as a measure for measure punishment for the nation's having wrongfully taken it to war.</point>
  26 KB (3,892 words) - 13:25, 24 July 2019
• Philosophy:Theodicy – צדיק ורע לו/2
  ...ecompense.&#160; We assume that something is a reward when it is in fact a punishment or vice versa.</p> ...ssible that an individual will undeservedly be included in the rewards (or punishment) aimed at another, and fall prey to the vicissitudes of chance.&#160; This,
  66 KB (10,151 words) - 01:04, 2 December 2020
• David's Counting of the Nation/2
  ...<a href="Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin" data-aht="page">Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</a>.</fn></li> ...is for this reason that the site of the Mikdash became known through their punishment and atonement.</fn>&#160; He might explain that David himself was spared si
  27 KB (3,995 words) - 22:18, 22 September 2019
• Biblical Parallels Index – Shemot 34/0
  ...of the calf.&#160; The wilderness period is marked by God's instantaneous punishment of the sinful, stemming from His direct presence in the nation's midst. Aft ...es that take different approaches to the issue of collective and vicarious punishment and gives an overview of commentators’ interpretations and resolutions of
  14 KB (2,158 words) - 14:24, 26 February 2024
• Shabbat Table Topics – Parashat Vayishlach/0/en
  ...policies of restraint versus active deterrence, the morality of collective punishment versus targeted killings, and the appropriate response to the use of human
  10 KB (1,506 words) - 05:07, 31 January 2020
• Reward and Punishment/2
  <h1>Reward and Punishment</h1> ...תם".&#160; It is possible, though, that here too, R"Y Albo is referring to collective physical rewards, but noting that also certain exceptional individuals, suc
  111 KB (16,500 words) - 11:37, 28 January 2023
• Moshe's Misstep and Mei Merivah/2
  ...f Korach. Seeing it would remind the nation of their recent grumblings and punishment.</fn> while R. Hirsch maintains that it was a sign of status, meant to asse ...</b> – Rashbam, Mendelssohn and R. Hirsch suggest that the severity of the punishment reflects the higher standards that Hashem demands of the righteous.</point>
  50 KB (7,994 words) - 11:36, 28 January 2023
• Overview – Sefer Bereshit/0
  ...e future exile in Bavel.</fn> He even claims that the future exile came as punishment for Avraham's initial descent and <a href="Endangering Sarai in Egypt" data ...ers of the tower of Bavel embarking on a malicious project that called for punishment, or, might their actions be viewed as an error in judgement and Hashem's in
  42 KB (6,488 words) - 11:52, 28 January 2023
• Biblical Parallels Index – Bemidbar 13-14/0
  .../sefer-devarim/parashat-devarim/devarim-1-sins-spies-and-nation-and-moshes-punishment">חטא המרגלים, חטא העם ועונשו של משה</a>, by R. A ...she's prayers allowed for a renewal of the covenant. No parallel repeal of punishment can be found after the sin of the spies. This factor might relate to the di
  19 KB (2,967 words) - 01:26, 6 May 2024
• Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins/2
  ...ence from various Biblical stories and prophecies which describe crime and punishment. In doing so, they attempt to present composite theories of how Divine just ...h, chart various compromise positions according to which justice is either collective or only semi-vicarious. They do so by positing that either both the parents
  153 KB (23,303 words) - 11:55, 28 January 2023
• Overview – Sefer Shemot/0/en
  <li><b>Punishment</b> – In setting penalties for crimes, which of the following objectives ...tive punishment justified?&#160; Can the same reasoning apply to vicarious punishment? See <a href="Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins" data-aht="page">Are
  29 KB (4,682 words) - 22:32, 21 August 2019
• The Suffering Servant in Yeshayahu 53/2/en
  ...es differ regarding whether or not this and similar verses imply vicarious punishment, and whether Israel really suffered "עַל לֹא חָמָס עָשָׂה" ...fn>This might stem from a general discomfort with the notion of collective punishment.&#160; Radak, for instance, opens his comments with the question, "הנה �
  58 KB (7,772 words) - 16:42, 26 August 2020
• Purposes of the Egyptian Bondage/2/en
  ...tween seeking candidates for a sin which might have deserved such a severe punishment, or trying to uncover non-punitive goals of the Egyptian experience. In doi ...l question becomes tangled in knotty theological issues such as collective punishment, children suffering for the sins of parents, afflictions of love, holding t
  76 KB (11,772 words) - 11:28, 28 January 2023
• Censuses in the Wilderness/2
  ...in Bemidbar are so detailed, repeating both the individual counts and the collective twice.</fn> Thus, Hashem counted the Israelites upon their departure from E ...n of the Golden Calf in Shemot 34.<fn>As it was only after the sin and its punishment that there was a need for a recount.</fn> See <a href="Purpose of the Mishk
  28 KB (4,473 words) - 07:21, 2 June 2019
• Sin and Slaughter of Shekhem/2
  ...and their personal stances on such questions as the validity of collective punishment or acts of deterrence. Many condone, and even laud, Shimon and Levi's actio ...icipated, to varying degrees, in the taking of Dinah, all deserved capital punishment.</p>
  45 KB (6,742 words) - 15:48, 4 July 2019
• Avraham/0/en
  ...arguments, condemning collective punishment, yet simultaneously requesting collective salvation. How do these requests relate to each other?&#160; [See <a href=" ...that Avraham was indeed praying for both the righteous and wicked, viewing collective salvation as a merciful act that transcends justice.</li>
  42 KB (6,144 words) - 00:12, 6 July 2023
• Overview – Sefer Shemot/0/he
  ...tive punishment justified?&#160; Can the same reasoning apply to vicarious punishment? ראו <a href="Are Children Punished for Parents' Sins" data-aht="page">� ....&#160; Is this the ultimate form of justice, or is it "cruel and unusual" punishment? How should the command to <a href="Annihilating Amalek" data-aht="page">מ
  31 KB (3,992 words) - 05:28, 22 August 2019
• Bizarre Prophetic Commands/2
  ...s leads him to conclude that there was a unique decree of collective total punishment on Anatot, from which even the righteous would not be spared (see Yirmeyahu
  28 KB (4,379 words) - 14:03, 24 July 2019
• The Suffering Servant in Yeshayahu 53/2/he
  ...will erroneously conclude that Israel's suffering must have been vicarious punishment for their own sins.</li> ...האם ה' פֹּקֵד עֲוֹן אָבֹת עַל בָּנִים?</a>, <a href="Philosophy:Collective Punishment" data-aht="page">ענישה קולקטיבית</a>, ו<a href="Philosophy:T
  61 KB (6,609 words) - 06:12, 4 September 2020
• Yaakov/0/en
  ...ing these as unjust, and preferred a policy of restraint and / or targeted punishment.&#160; Commentators differ regarding what exactly he had thought would happ ...in Hashem.&#160; Rashbam even suggests that the attack by the angel was a punishment for this lack of trust.<fn>See also&#160;<multilink><a href="RadakBereshit3
  67 KB (9,806 words) - 03:51, 9 June 2023
• Moshe/0
  ...r! How, then, is the story to be understood?&#160; Is it a tale of sin and punishment or something else? For details, see <a href="Mystery at the Malon" data-aht ...all three cases the leg is specifically chosen as a "measure for measure" punishment for not going to do what Hashem desired. For more on Rashbam's reading of e
  88 KB (13,049 words) - 05:58, 13 February 2024
• Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin/5
  <h1>Collective Punishment for Akhan's Sin</h1> ...of secret thoughts for these belong to the Lord our God and He will exact punishment from that individual; but those things which are revealed belong to us and
  86 KB (4,458 words) - 12:25, 28 January 2023
• Purpose of the Mishkan/2/en
  ...eir gratitude to and respect for Hashem. Thus, all of the nation's initial collective and creative labors are dedicated to Hashem in the form of the Tabernacle.< ...f Israel and created the need for them to observe all of the mitzvot (as a punishment) rather than merely achieving salvation by having simple faith. According t
  61 KB (9,609 words) - 11:45, 28 January 2023
• Index:Resource Articles/0
  ...Q_VRvnLhhQ7E_INPziBkyoePKfNW8MW0nV0QXjCcjGiNk#.Uk5wTD-F2UV">Individual and Collective Responsibility</a>, Rabbi Jonathan Sacks. Rabbi Sacks argues that the gener ...ommentary on Parashat Ki Tavo and his interpretation that the curses are a punishment for rejection of the system of mitzvot rather than laxness of observance.</
  54 KB (7,619 words) - 22:57, 11 April 2024
• Commentators:R. Moshe b. Nachman (Ramban, Nachmanides)/0
  ...m, in which Ramban discusses various theological issues such as reward and punishment, the World to Come, and Resurrection.</fn> and possibly Iggeret HaMusar.<fn ...ng <a href="Tzara'at" data-aht="page">Tzara'at</a>), Vayikra 18:28 (on the punishment of Karet), Vayikra 19:19 (on the <a href="Purpose of the Laws of Hybrids" d
  94 KB (13,267 words) - 02:52, 29 May 2023
• Philosophy:Collective Punishment/5
  <h1>Collective Punishment</h1> ...se they worshipped these as gods. When the Holy One, blessed be He, exacts punishment from a nation, He punishes their gods at the same time (cf. Mekhilta on 12:
  249 KB (8,802 words) - 12:48, 28 January 2023
• Commentators:R. David Kimchi (Radak)/5
  ...men. Still others believe that all the large sea monsters are known by the collective name of “Leviathan.” The scholar Rabbi Avraham bar Chiya wrote that the ...part of His universe are up to, and that He even will not exact collective punishment unless He can demonstrate that the parties affected are all guilty. There w
  267 KB (22,361 words) - 08:22, 23 August 2023
• Bereshit 15 – One Prophecy or Two/5
  ...d to him, אל תירא אברם אנכי מגן לך FEAR NOT ABRAM, I AM THY SHIELD against punishment: for you shall not be punished on account of all these people whom you have ...d is called גוזל by the Torah. Basically, all small birds are known by the collective name of גוזל, as for instances in Deuteronomy 32,11 where the Torah des
  191 KB (11,355 words) - 00:58, 11 November 2022
• Tzara'at/5
  ...f good tidings, and we hold our peace; if we tarry till the morning light, punishment will overtake us; now therefore come, let us go and tell the king's househo ...CEDAR WOOD </b> – This lofty tree was used because plagues come also as a punishment for haughtiness (cf. ib.). <br/><b>ושני תולעת ואזוב AND CRIMS
  343 KB (16,894 words) - 11:39, 28 January 2023
• Nature of the Asham/5
  <br/><b>to atone for him</b> to release him from the punishment due him.</text> ...d his theft - his sin will not be atoned. However, we can suppose that his punishment will not be so strong as it would have been, had he not returned the money.
  267 KB (18,970 words) - 11:30, 28 January 2023